Obviously there’s been a lot of talk lately about this whole economic stimulus package that is trying to be passed here in the United States, but other countries have now started to add in their own versions — the UK, Australia, Iceland (bad luck there, dudes), and others. It’s all in the name of trying to get things back to “normal”, where that is indicated by more people making money and doing well than not. And right now, most of us are either starting to falter, have stumbled, or are flat on our faces and sizing up where, exactly, we would put the KitchenAid in the cardboard box.
I’ve thought a lot about this entire idea of the stimulus, have listened religiously to NPR’s Planet Money podcasts concerning various opinions and analysis, and have thought about my own situation as well as that of others. Despite recent polls indicating that support for the bill is falling amongst Americans, I still feel it’s a good idea, but the manner in how to go about it is the tricky part.
Tax relief? Good. Tax credits? Not bad, but harder to see right away. Infrastructure spending? Great for the long term if done right, huge sinkhole of a money pit if done wrong. The sides on that one are pretty slippery, too, I’m afraid. Corporate tax cuts? Uhm…didn’t we try that one already? Yeah, it didn’t work.
I think the hardest part for everyone is quantifying what, exactly, is going to happen that will concern us, personally. I mean…I’m big enough and smart enough to look at the whole picture. I very well know that infrastructure spending, while a slow, long-haul poke in the ass of the economy, will ultimately make us a better country and we’ll be glad we did it in, say, 5 to 10 years. But to be honest, RIGHT NOW, it doesn’t mean Jack M. Squat to me in terms of my day-to-day needs and necessities.
Giving me more money to take home is a great way to say, “Perk up! Stimulate the economy!” But that depends on how much it is. $50 a paycheck isn’t going to go much farther than things do now, and I’m likely to look at that and think, “Well, I could…uh….buy another case of ramen??” whereas a significantly larger amount, say, $300, is another car payment, or mortgage boost, or a debt payment, or….there’s a lot more options for that kind of cash than a five-0h carries.
It also matters in terms of where I am versus where others are. I still have a good, decent-paying job, and feel secure that I won’t be gone anytime soon (although nobody feels 100% secure and, rightly so). There are tons of folks out there, however (and getting worse every day), that aren’t emloyed or at least not enough, and they’re looking at the stimulus package in a whole different light, more as a savior to impossible conditions rather than a boost.
I’m certainly not of the opinion that everyone should get a huge handout. For one, in such a situation, you HAVE to have some people on the rocks, some business failing, and some jobs lost and so forth, otherwise nobody has motivation and the system becomes a welfare state and not an opportunistic one. BUT, that all being said, it makes sense that we’d try to at least keep the majority of folks in good shape when possible.
What do I need? Well, if I have to be completely selfish, here’s what MY stimulus would look like:
- More take-home money in the paycheck, of a significant amount. Iowa, take back your silly agricultural taxes (god, state taxes here are stupid-high), and federal, ease up a bit. I’m happy to pay for roads, but — honestly.
- Debt relief in the form of lower interest rates and longer pay periods. Don’t know what government could do about that, but making things stretch out would sure be handy. I’m happy enough to pay off my debts, but making it easier to buy groceries would be really kickass.
- Offer the option to have a forbearance on student loan payments for a year. Look, I’m in it till 2021 right now; I’m not in a hurry, so…can I just take a year off? Charge me interest if you will, but let me forget about that one for a bit, hrm? They’re so…annoying.
- Since I’m one of those who has a house that I can actually pay for and afford, make it easy to get monies or credits for improving our properties. Not only will we get more efficiency, but we’ll see urban renewal, and that has to be a positive.
Really, in a nutshell, those are the things that will matter to me most, given my situation and place in life right now. I’ll probably get a few of those things, but doubtful if I’ll get them all.
Now it’s YOUR turn — tell us what would stimulate you and why it would make a big difference in your life. If we’re lucky, a Senator’s reading this right now.


Personally, I’d really like a job right now. Or unemployment benefits. Since I haven’t lived in Iowa for the last 18 months, I do not qualify for unemployment. That really sucks considering I’ve lived in Iowa for 30 of my 33 years and started paying into unemployment when I was 14. Obviously I would rather have a job but I don’t see the State of Iowa trying to keep anyone here. We can’t even get the flood money that those cities and individuals have been waiting for since June. I rec’d my IA car registration this week: almost $300. I also rec’d my FL car regiatration this week: $36.10. No state income tax there either. If it weren’t for all the old people I’d be back there in a heartbeat. Oh, and I need my family/friends to move too. (Shall we carpool?) Mostly, I wish they would stop using the word stimulus. Isn’t that what was supposed to happen with the last check we got? Didn’t work. I have no faith in the government and am REALLY tired of the Obama commercials urging our State Republican Senator to vote for this pork bill. How much money is being wasted in each state to air these commercials that sound like campaign commercials? They need to focus, focus, focus and stop pushing their own agendas. Ok, I realize this was a rant. Sorry… I’m unemployed and have a lot of time these days. Bring it on!
Interesting post. I learn some things from reading your blog.
I like the idea of getting money to improve homes and properties. I’d just hope that people would only be allowed to spend it on home improvements. That would be a lot of money going to people though. Homes are expensive to fix. :/ Especially around some parts here in Metro/Detroit where it would just be better to burn and start over
Detroit is getting busy with knocking down a lot of burned down neighborhoods from the riots and building nice apartments and things. So that’s part of a urban renewal project here.
I get yearly forbearance on my student loans. Mine is actually ending this month but I’m going to apply for another since I’m unemployed. I used the Stafford loan company and the people there are really nice and understanding. They base the forbearance on my taxes and income and a written statement. I still get charged interest but it’s a lot better than paying $100 or more every month when I’m trying to buy food or pay for car insurance or keep my home from the bank
I don’t know what company you used or if it was a bank, but that’s how mine works.
Also, I wish that small debt could just be eliminated somehow. I have a few cards that are under $5000 and I’m having a hard time making payments because everything is messed up from being unemployed. It’s annoying having my credit be destroyed by debt that’s so small. I wish that CC companies could just make some sort of decision based on past payment history/income/taxes/situation and just eliminate or most of it. Or have a student loan forbearance above.
I called and worked small payments out with their lawyers but seriously. Don’t they have bigger fish to fry? I’ve made the irritating calls, begging to lower my interest rates, and they’ve worked..but it’s still a pain.
I know it doesn’t sound responsible and it was I who made the debt but honestly. I got court summons to Waterloo for $2000 from Veridian Credit Union
I would like banks to be required to renegotiate mortgages regardless of the balance remaining. I was watching CNN a few days ago and a woman wrote in to Suze Orman that she only owed another 20K on her mortgage, but she got a smaller paying job and couldn’t afford the mortgage payment. Her mortgage holder is refusing to help her out. For the bank it’s a no-brainer – she reneges on her mortgage, they take the house and make a killing because she only owes 20k! It’s just not fair. That’s not really stimulus, but… it would help. I can’t imagine that she’s the only person in that situation.
Courtneys blog: Lucky You – Three Memes In One Post